Acts 19:2
He said unto them, Have ye received the Holy Ghost since ye believed? And they said unto him, We have not so much as heard whether there be any Holy Ghost.
Cross-references
In Acts 19:5, these same disciples are baptized after Paul's teaching — showing their immediate response to learning about the Holy Spirit.
Acts 2:38 promises the Holy Spirit after repentance and baptism — precisely what these disciples had not yet received, showing their incomplete initiation.
Acts 8:15-17 parallels this scene — believers baptized but lacking the Spirit, receiving it through apostolic prayer and laying on of hands.
Acts 8:16 describes a similar case: believers baptized but not yet having received the Holy Spirit.
Acts 11:16 recalls the promise of Spirit baptism vs John's water baptism — these disciples only had the latter.
Acts 2:17 records the prophecy of the Spirit's outpouring — these disciples had not even heard of that promise, highlighting their surprising ignorance.
Acts 10:44 shows the Spirit falling spontaneously on Cornelius's household — a different pattern from these disciples who needed instruction about the Spirit.
Acts 11:15-17 recounts that God gave the same Holy Spirit to Gentiles — these disciples were initially missing that same gift given to all believers.
Acts 2:39 extends the promise of the Spirit to all who are far off — these Ephesian disciples are among those called, yet unaware of it.
In John 7:39, the Spirit had not yet been given — explaining why these disciples had not heard of him.
Galatians 3:2 directly echoes Paul's question: 'Did you receive the Spirit by works or by hearing with faith?'
John 1:33 prophesied Jesus would baptize with the Spirit — these disciples only knew John's water baptism.
John 20:22 records Jesus imparting the Spirit to the disciples — a gift these Ephesians had not received.